Hiring and Retention in the Public Sector
How city practices have evolved, and what’s next
Municipal workforces shape how governments interact with their constituents and provide key services such as sanitation, water, emergency help, and libraries. But the COVID-19 pandemic prompted many workers to leave their jobs, straining public and municipal services as well as residents’ experiences with their local government. A new policy brief from The Pew Charitable Trusts explores how the workforces of 10 big-city governments have rebounded and shows that many have largely returned to their pre-pandemic sizes, although not every city nor in every department. New York, Los Angeles, and Philadelphia, for example, still have far fewer public safety personnel per capita than they did pre-COVID.
To explore this topic, on Oct. 22 Pew’s Philadelphia research and policy initiative hosted a webinar on “Progress and Pressure: Municipal Staffing Post-Pandemic.”
Moderating the hour-long conversation was Caitlin Lewis, executive director of Work for America, a nonprofit committed to making careers in public service more desirable and accessible. The panelists were Elizabeth Linos, faculty director of The People Lab at the Harvard Kennedy School of Government, and Gerald Young, senior researcher at the MissionSquare Research Institute. The experts stressed that the issues that local governments now face in recruiting and retaining qualified workers date back at least to the 2007-09 Great Recession, when many municipalities laid off workers and/or froze hiring. Some of those issues were exacerbated by the pandemic.
The experts also discussed current challenges, which include:
- Dealing with employee burnout. Surveys show that the percentage of local government workers citing high levels of stress has declined somewhat from the COVID-19 years. But the sense of burnout remains a major reason cited by municipal employees who are considering leaving their positions. “It’s certainly not a problem that was created by the pandemic,” Linos said, nor is it one that will go away on its own. For all of the stresses, many of the workers thinking about new jobs still say they want to remain in the public sector, citing benefits such as pensions and health coverage and the ability to serve their communities.
- Hiring into hard-to-fill positions. Recruiters in municipalities throughout the nation often struggle to find qualified people to fill jobs in such fields as engineering, nursing, and information technology as well as public safety. But according to Young this situation, like the overall picture, has improved in the last few years. In 2021 and 2022, governments were getting fewer applicants in those areas than they had vacant positions; since then, he said there has been “steady improvement.”
- Attracting talented people to local government. Many members of the public have little conception about the range of jobs available in local government, who takes them, or the skill level required. This is especially true among college students, who often have negative stereotypes about the nature of public employment and lack an understanding about what Young calls the “total value of compensation” in the public sector, which includes benefits and hourly wages. Lewis added that these jobs come with a “sense of impact and purpose [that] cannot be understated.”
- Using artificial intelligence. Many governments rely on decades-old information systems, which may limit their use of AI in hiring and retention. Where feasible, AI can help managers shortlist candidates by quickly screening out applicants who lack the required qualifications to make it through the process. The tool can also help manage the large volume of applications generated when candidates use AI to apply for multiple positions with minimal effort.
The event’s overall takeaway was: While the post-pandemic numbers for municipal workforces have rebounded, the hiring and retention challenges aren’t going away. This is especially true for high-skill positions, where candidates may be lured by the private sector. If cities are to provide essential services in the years ahead, it is critical that they address those challenges.
Larry Eichel is a senior adviser to The Pew Charitable Trusts’ Philadelphia research and policy initiative.